|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
3fingercharlie
Crustacean

|
|
 |
« #17 : 01-05-2002 09:54 »
|
|
Or perhaps he's asleep in your closet!! [goes stiff and falls off chair]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Teral

Helpy McHelphelp
DOOP Secretary

|
|
 |
« #24 : 03-26-2002 14:42 »
|
|
Originally posted by Otis P Jivefunk: I'm probably thinking too much into this but, if benders head has been buried in the sand since 1947, doesn’t that mean that everything which had happened in benders life to that point, didnt happen? If I'm reading your question right Otis, the answer is no. It just mean that there were two versions of Benders head in the period from Benders activation/assembly 'til the time of the supernova. The one attached to Benders body and the one burried in the desert. The head attached to Benders body would still experience Benders life as it always was.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Otis P Jivefunk

DOOP Secretary

|
|
 |
« #26 : 03-26-2002 15:00 »
|
|
Originally posted by Teral: If I'm reading your question right Otis, the answer is no. It just mean that there were two versions of Benders head in the period from Benders activation/assembly 'til the time of the supernova. The one attached to Benders body and the one burried in the desert.
The head attached to Benders body would still experience Benders life as it always was. Teral, you bring up a very good point but thinking this through it would mean that everything that had happened in the previous episodes would have happened twice. Once with the Bender who's head was lost in 1947, and once with a different Bender which would be made at the same time the previous Bender had been made. Only this time the previous Bender's head would be buried while the new Bender would be doing everything that the original Bender had done until the point the previous Bender was dug up. That would mean there are two Benders, but why go back for the original Bender (head) when they are essentially the same and have both lived through exactly the same things and experiences up until that point in time?
|
|
|
|
|
Teral

Helpy McHelphelp
DOOP Secretary

|
|
 |
« #27 : 03-26-2002 15:03 »
« : 03-26-2002 15:03 »
|
|
Edit: This was directed at Spiff's post. Nothing. Just ask Data.  Besides Bender seems to understand the problems about changing history, he pretty much said so himself in Roswell. So he would probably shut up, and act like he was some other bending robot. Of course if you're more to the "Time Cop" explanation then Benders head would be destroyed. Same matter can't occopy the same space. 
|
|
|
|
|
Teral

Helpy McHelphelp
DOOP Secretary

|
|
 |
« #28 : 03-26-2002 15:18 »
« : 03-26-2002 15:18 »
|
|
Originally posted by Otis P Jivefunk: Teral, you bring up a very good point but thinking this through it would mean that everything that had happened in the previous episodes would have happened twice.
Once with the Bender who's head was lost in 1947, and once with a different Bender which would be made at the same time the previous Bender had been made. Only this time the previous Bender's head would be buried while the new Bender would be doing everything that the original Bender had done until the point the previous Bender was dug up. That would mean there are two Benders, but why go back for the original Bender (head) when they are essentially the same and have both lived through exactly the same things and experiences up until that point in time?
Ah, time travel, paradoxes, wonderfull stuff. Problem is, they (Fry, Leela etc) didn't have any other choice than to go dig up Bender's head. The head original attached to Benders body was lost in 1947. 299?: Benders head is made 299? - 21 september 3002: Bender leads his life 21 september 3002: travels back in time 1947 - 22 september 3002: burried in New Mexico 22 september 3002: reattached. As of 21 september 3002 there would be two heads with essential the same memories of Benders life until that point, so in a sense you could say that things has happened twice, but from the perspective of each of Bender's heads, they didn't. He lead a straight enough life (just took a detour of 1055 years). Each head experienced the life described above. IMH(and nitpickish)O, ofcourse. 
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
BrainSluggo

Starship Captain
   
|
|
 |
« #32 : 03-26-2002 21:05 »
« : 03-26-2002 23:00 »
|
|
Time itself is a state of change; this negates the Timecop/Back To The Future theory. You, three minutes ago, were not exactly the same You as You are right now. Or now. Or now. Brain cells are recording more useless garbage than a VCR could in eons, molecules are vibrating, blood is coursing, cells are dividing, mitochondria are crapping, tumors are growing, kidneys and bowels are eliminating, parasites are eating, wax and underarm bacteria excrements are accumulating. And everything's aging rapidly. In seven years, almost every cell in your body will have been replaced. Many of them died and were replaced while you were reading this word here. Why are you wasting your precious time reading this horsehockey? Let's continue.
So You can't take You from three seconds/years/decades from now and make You blow up by throwing You at Yourself now, because the only thing that's likely to be exactly the same would be Your first name and that rank odor You emit. The only way to make the theory work is to take You and throw You at You at the exact moment You were taken in order to throw You at You. But that won't work because You were just taken.
Besides, two of anything can't occupy the same space at the same time. Here, I'll try to shove an atom from a pencil into the exact same space as an atom from my eye.
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!! J**** H. Lapdancing C*****!! Ow ow ow ow ow!
...but you see, the eye and bone and brain went around the pencil. They can't occupy the same space at the same time. Nothing can. (I'd show you a variation of this experiment, but the FBI took away my fissionable material.) Science-fiction just likes to suggest that "the same space" has a ridiculously imprecise boundary.
There is only one Bender head. There were two Bender heads in existence at the same time for a brief period, but they are the "same" head with different experiences and of different ages and other conditions. One does not negate or otherwise affect the other. If I threw a pencil into a time warp and it fell onto my desk five minutes ago, there would be two pencils there for five minutes, but it's basically the same object--one would be different for just having fallen out of a time warp--but in five minutes, it wouldn't make any difference, because if I don't huck the pencil into the time warp and start stabbing myself with the one that fell onto my desk, then none of it will have happened. Which leads to another fun aspect of Weapons-Grade Balonium in Sci-Fudge...
As far as this whole Terminator-causality thing goes, if time is linear, it doesn't matter if someone goes back in time and changes the past, thereby altering the future so that they don't go back in time. All that matters is that they popped up at one point, affecting that point in time. What do you care? Sure, in an alternate timeline you used to be Bill God Almighty, but now you're just a poor slob with a goiter because I threw a pencil into a time warp.
Ha ha.
I have to lay down now. All this thinking and stabbing make my brain hurt
|
|
|
|
|
futurefreak

salutatory committee member
Moderator
DOOP Secretary

|
|
 |
« #33 : 04-02-2011 20:15 »
|
|
Everyone raise their hands who've seen "Roswell that Ends Well." FF, keep your hand down.
Haha, Oh wow @ myself. In the Holiday Spectacular after the ship crushed Fry and Leela and the crew, was there enough alcohol on board to power Bender that whole time until he got the oil he needed? Or do you think he went for long periods in a sleep mode?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|