PEELies 2010 - Award nominations.

[on:]

Alright, We're not taking nominations for PEELers to win things yet.

We're taking nominations for what awards you'd like to see up for grabs. You can suggest as many awards as you like, I and my helpoer-elves will pick the best of them, and we'll open nominations for the PEELers to win 'em shortly. Any questions, PM me rather than spamming up this thread. Spam will be removed.

Things that have been popular in the past.:

PILF (PEELer I'd like to fuck)

PEELer of the year

n00b of the year

Worst PEELer

Best PEELer


Those should give you an idea of what we're likely to go with. Get suggesting.

[Reply #1 on:]

What was the difference between PEELer of the Year and Best PEELer again?

[Reply #2 on:]

Quiet, you. There's no difference except one year we had ther first one and another year we had the second one. Just suggest the awards you'd like to see up for grabs and quit commenting on my logical inconsistencies.

[Reply #3 on:]

Haha, right.
Maybe dived Best PEELer into Best Male and Best Female?
Best Thread
Best Comeback
Best Custom Avatar
Most Missed PEELer

That's what I can think of right now.

[Reply #4 on:]

Is there any call for a noob of the year this year? I don't think so somehow since all the really nooby noobs are this year.

Anyhow, I know in the past there's been a call for Best thread title and best picture

So there's a couple.

[Reply #5 on:]

Here are some of my ideas:

• The Honorable Mention Award for Most On-Topic PEEer
• The Shiny Memorial Award for Shippiest PEELer
• The "Hey, You!" Award for Most Original New Username
• PEELer Most Likely to Disappear Down the Memory Hole

[Reply #6 on:]

What about Best Newbie?

[Reply #7 on:]

Post of the year?  Or is that too in depth?

Most likely to be banned?

[Reply #8 on:]

Haha, right.
Maybe dived Best PEELer into Best Male and Best Female?

<snip>

Yes, and also a Best Androgynous/indeterminate gender PEELer.

[Reply #9 on:]

Last year we had Best Framegrab Captioner. I liked that Gen Diss was represented.

[Reply #10 on:]

Is there any call for a noob of the year this year? I don't think so somehow since all the really nooby noobs are this year.

Well, since it is the awards for 2010, there have been some good noobs there. Like yourself


I made a list of noobs from 2010 with 100 posts or more (sorted by post count):

Show spoiler

Nutmeg1729


Free Hot Meal


Nibblonian Leader


CommanderZapp


mazda07


Louiswuenator


SweetZombieJesus


MadFellow


Tachyon


EvilChicken


pluche93


Fnord


MovieMurderer


jeepdavetj


SorynArkayn




Well, and technically (but it's really just Books):

Christopher

Show spoiler

Nutmeg and FHM are the only 2 with more than 1000 posts, Nibs with around 600 is still way ahead of the others though.

[Reply #11 on:]

Best Male
Best Female
Best Thread
Best Comeback
Best Custom Avatar
Most Missed PEELer

That's what I can think of right now.

• The Honorable Mention Award for Most On-Topic PEEer
• The Shiny Memorial Award for Shippiest PEELer
• The "Hey, You!" Award for Most Original New Username
• PEELer Most Likely to Disappear Down the Memory Hole

Best Newbie?

Best Framegrab Captioner

All good ideas. Keep 'em coming, and we'll whittle it down to the best... umm, dozen or so? Just keep 'em coming.

Let me just point out that things like this can be suggested...

Worst PEELer
Most annoying PEELer
Least Missed PEELer
n00biest n00b
The Nurdbot: Bad Spelling Award

I know others have frowned on "negative" awards, but I see no reason not to represent them.

If you agree or disagree with any suggestions so far, just say so and state your reasoning.

[Reply #12 on:]

So far it looks like really good strong suggestions for the awards.  I'll have to think about it, if I'm to come up with anything original and PEELculiar....

[Reply #13 on:]

• The Tin-Foil Hat Award for Most Paranoid PEELer
• The Ebony Malfoy Mary-Sue Award for Best Fanfiction Writer
• The Raging Brainer Award for Most Intellectually Stimulating PEELer
• The Serious Business Award for Most Humourless PEEler

[Reply #14 on:]

Have we ever had a Best Debate Thread? Or Debater for that matter?

Debater? He hardly knew her!

[Reply #15 on:]

That award is negative? I can't tell at all!

[Reply #16 on:]

Haha, right.
Maybe dived Best PEELer into Best Male and Best Female?

<snip>

Yes, and also a Best Androgynous/indeterminate gender PEELer.

LOL...yes.


Many of these have been mentioned in some form, but I think Best new PEELer of 2010, Best old PEELer of 2010, Best new custom avatar, Best artistic PEELer of 2010?, Best thread title...a lot of good ones have been mentioned.  I might add more if I come up with them.

EDIT: PEELer most likely to give up

[Reply #17 on:]

Best new custom avatar could be a pain to remember all that were from 2010...

[Reply #18 on:]

PEELer most likely to suck cock for votes/attention?

That one is a bit negative though.

[Reply #19 on:]

Depends if they like cock.

[Reply #20 on:]

Best new custom avatar could be a pain to remember all that were from 2010...

I haven't seen much change at all with the avatars since I joined in September (I don't think Christmas avys should count).  Since Sept that leaves, Nutmeg, FHM, SoS, tnuk (twice), Morgan, and 1 other PEELer I can't remember the name of as the custom changes I have seen.

PEELer most likely to suck cock for votes/attention?

That one is a bit negative though.

I think I know who you are talking about.

[Reply #21 on:]

I wasn't referring to anyone in particular, actually.

[Reply #22 on:]

Sorry.
Like I said, I over-analyze stuff way too much.  I was raised by my mom and that is exactly how she acts.  I guess it just rubbed off to me and after 24 years...boom!, now I am the same way.

[Reply #23 on:]

I like Most Missed Poster, as long as we call it "The Welshy Award for Most Missed".

A personal favorite that I'd like return is "Most Likely to Cause the Apocalypse".

And, if we're going to allow negative: "Most Likely to Die a Virgin" and "Most Likely to Have a Yet-Discovered STD". They're negative, but the latter at least implies the poster is getting some.

[Reply #24 on:]

Well, the STD could also be caused by uhm... other none human sex

[Reply #25 on:]

Doesn't matter, had sex.

[Reply #26 on:]

And, if we're going to allow negative: "Most Likely to Die a Virgin" [...]

You're just jealous that some people have the option to spend the rest of their lives riding unicorns.

[Reply #27 on:]

Do you just need V-plates to ride a unicorn on a public highway?

I nominate Best Finder of Cool Stuff (News, pics, vids) for being an award.

[Reply #28 on:]

More....

Most Interesting PEEler
Funniest PEELer
Best European PEELer
Best US PEELer
Best Aussie/NZ/anywhere else PEELer
Most Mysterious PEELer
PEELer you would most like to start a new thread title...or this could be PEELer you would most like to spend a day with
Best Spammer
The winna awards....ie most random PEELer

Edited for spelling mistake...good catch i_c_weiner.

[Reply #29 on:]

More....

Best European PEELer
Best US PEELer
Best Aussie/NZ/anywhere else PEELer

Shall we divide PEELers up into DVD regions instead?

[Reply #30 on:]

Or Blu regions? Those are less.


And if we do best Asian peeler it's kinda a 1 horse run, no?

[Reply #31 on:]

Email is now up and running for this, with the exceptions of the "best noob" category, all nominations and votes for the chosen categories will go to the email located in my signature.

I'll make tnuk write a longer post about this when it comes down to it.

[Reply #32 on:]

Or Blu regions? Those are less.


And if we do best Asian peeler it's kinda a 1 horse run, no?

That was the problem I faced.  It seems the 2 biggest regions are Europe and the US, with Austria/NZ coming in third...then where do you lump in people who don't live in those 3 regions?  If this is too complicated (I'll certainly understand that), then we can just do something else.

[Reply #33 on:]

We tried this one year, all it did was give certain obvious choices more awards.

And, if we're going to allow negative: "Most Likely to Die a Virgin" [...]

You're just jealous that some people have the option to spend the rest of their lives riding unicorns.

New award suggestion: Most Likely to Seen Riding a Unicorn

More....

Most Misterious PEELer

I think we have a nominee for TNUK's suggestion of the Nurdbot Bad Spelling Award!!!


Speaking of which, could we expand Worst Spelling to Worst English in general?

[Reply #34 on:]

PEELer most likely to be secretly gay
PEELer least likely to benefit society with the wells they dug
Best car that actually belongs to a PEELer

Just drunken thoughts...

[Reply #35 on:]

Which reminds me...
Most Drujknen PEELer

[Reply #36 on:]

What was the difference between PEELer of the Year and Best PEELer again?

It's the same sort of difference in how there is Song of the Year and Best Album of the Year for the Grammies.

[Reply #37 on:]

Not really.

[Reply #38 on:]

It was a stretch, but I tried.

And the more I think about it, Best PEELer could only be for 2010 (not over all the years), hence the same as Best PEELer of 2010.

[Reply #39 on:]

The best Album / best Song comparison would be more of a best Thread / best Sub-Forum, no?