Category Discussion

[on:]

Again we want to open up category selection to everyone.  Some might need to be removed, maybe renamed.  Or you might have a new suggestion

Here is the complete list of awards we used last year
Most Valuable PEELer 2007
Greatest Debate of 2007
Fantasy Mod
Fiend of WikiPEELia
The PEEL Attention sleeper Award
Second Life
Most Likely to Become a Serial Killer
The Old World PEELer
The Façade Award
The Humor Bot 5.0 Award
MOST BADDEST ENGRISH
PILF Award
The Tay Zonday Award
Best Fanfictionist
The Captain's Itch Award (best new thread)
Monk's Lost Brother
Best Comeback
This Represents Me
Most Addicted to PEEL
Most Foul Mouthed
The Subtle Self-Loathing Award
Most Creative New Username
The Outback Expertised PEELer
Poster of the Month of the Year
Most Immature PEELer
Most Likely to Unexpectedly Run into Chris Hansen
Best *New* PEELer
Best Signature
Best Fanartist
Shippiest PEELer
Itchy Crotch Execupowder Award for very *friendly* persontiest PEELer
The +1 Mace Award for Nerdiest PEELer
Most Annoying PEELer
The New World PEELer
The Foreign PEELer
Heart & Soul of the Group
Self-Reliance
PEELer Least in Touch with Reality
Lifetime Achievement Award
PEELPic of the Year


We also have a list of all the categories we discussed having at all.  Some of these are repeats, so I'll spoiler it so this post isnt ridiculously long

# Lifetime Achievement Award

# Most Valuable PEELer 2007

# Poster of the Month of the Year - PotMotY (must be a PotM winner)

# Wisdom Comes with Age - Best Old PEELer (over 35 years of age)

# The Jailbait Award - Best Young PEELer (under 16 years of age)

# Best Fanartist

# Best Fanfictionist

# Mark Twain's Favorite - Best Fanfiction

# Most Disturbing FanArt/FanFic

# Shippiest PEELer

# PEELer Most Likely to Snog a Futurama Character



# Captain's Itch Award - Best New Thread

# Greatest Debate of 2007

# Best #FC Character

# Most Helpful PEELer

# Fantasy Mod Award (most likely to be a moderator)

# Fiend of WikiPEELia



# "Make That Pregnant Dog Your Pregnant Dog, You Bastard!" - Most Foul Mouthed

# The Humor Bot 5.0 Award (funniest PEELer)

# You've Got Sash - Sassiest PEELer

# FuJck as [Drujnk] - Drunkest PEELer

# Most Baddest Engrish

# Daddy Bender Award (PEELer who would/could be the worst parent)



# Itchy Crotch Execupowder Award for very *friendly* persontiest PEELer (PEELer must be 18+ years of age)

# PEELer Most Likely to Poke Naked Pictures of Themselves

# PILF Award (PEELer I'd Like to Frak)

# DramaQueen Award - Most Immature PEELer

# "Check Out My Myspace" - The PEEL Attention sleeper Award

# The Subtle Self-Loathing Award



# Capitalism - Biggest Consumer sleeper

# SecondLife - PEELer with Most Interesting Life Outside of PEEL

# Triforce of Finding Interesting Stuff and Sharing It

# PEELPic of the Year



# Chris Hansen is Coming - Most Likely to be Convicted of Sexual Deviancy
# Most Likely to Unexpectedly Run into Chris Hansen

# PEELer Most Likely to Become a Serial Killer

# "Nice Myspace Page!" - Most Likely Stalker Award

# Evil - PEELer Who to Turn Innocence into Nightmare

# Most Apocalyptic PEELer (PEELer most likely to bring end days)



# Self-Reliance - PEELer Most Likely to Die Masturbating

# Monk's Lost Brother (quirkiest odd PEELer)

# PEELer Least in Touch with Reality

# PEELer Most Likely to be a Fake Account

# Axis of Evil - PEEL Group That Wields Most Power over PEEL Affairs



# The Welshy Award - Most Missed PEELer

# Best Comeback

# Best New PEELer

# Most Creative New Username

# This Represents Me - Best Avatar

# Best Signature



# Most Underrated PEELer

# Most Overrated PEELer

# Most Addicted to PEEL



# The Hubert J. Farnsworth Award (smartest PEELer)

# The +1 Mace Award for Nerdiest PEELer

# The Tay Zonday Award for Most Likely to be a Internet Celebrity

# Evolution? - Most Likely to Garner a Darwin Award



# PEELer So Vain They Probably Think this Award is About Them

# Beaten to Death - Most Annoying PEELer

# Least Valueable PEELer - The Homerjaysimpson Award

# PEELer Most Likely to Not Win Anything



The PEEL MeetUp Awards (PEELers who met at a PEEL gathering in 2006/2007)
---------------------------------------------------------
# New World PEELer (most entertaining PEELer from the Americas)

# The Queen's Favourite PEELer (most entertaining PEELer from UK/Australia/NZ)

# The Foreigner (most entertaining PEELer from a nation whose native language is not English)

# Heart and Soul of the Group [Name suggestion for Frequent Flyer (PEELer to touch Most PEELers)

# The Facade Award (PEELer least like their internet persona)

One thing the council has already talked about is scrapping the Peel Meetup awards for this year.  Since there hasn't been a large meeting this year, its likely that these would be repeat awards.

DISCUSS/SUGGEST/ARGUE!

[Reply #1 on:]

Too many titles, we could just make one up for each member.

[Reply #2 on:]

gudbjorg makes a good pjoint.  I count 67 categories in the spoilered list.

[Reply #3 on:]

Well maybe gudbjorg should just join the PEELies Council then

[Reply #4 on:]

We should set a maximum number of catagories and keep to that limit or else we'll end up with tons of them. Just pick a number like 30 or 50 or something.

[Reply #5 on:]

Well maybe gudbjorg should just join the PEELies Council then

I... have

[Reply #6 on:]

Umm..  I said the spoilers one is all the categories we talked about, and then narrowed down, I didn't suggest that we use all of them.

Anyways, I was thinking about "coolest custom title"

[Reply #7 on:]

gudbjorg makes a good pjoint.  I count 67 categories in the spoilered list.

Yeah we cut like 20 off the top of that.


My take (20 categories):

Most Valuable PEELer 2008

Greatest Debate of 2008

Fiend of WikiPEELia '08

The Façade Award

The Humor Bot 5.0 Award

PILF Award

Best Fanfictionist

The Captain's Itch Award (best new thread)

Best Comeback

This Represents Me (Avatar 08)

Most Addicted to PEEL

Most Creative New Username

Best *New* PEELer

Best Signature

Best Fanartist

Itchy Crotch Execupowder Award for very *friendly* personiest PEELer

The +1 Mace Award for Nerdiest PEELer

PEELer Least in Touch with Reality

Lifetime Achievement Award

PEELPic of the Year

Nothing new there... I don't have any fresh ideas... I'm a loser.

[Reply #8 on:]

The Fa็ade Award?

PILF Award?

Please explain.

[Reply #9 on:]

Façade award was for the one least like their internet personal, and PILF is PEELer I'd Like to Fuck.

[Reply #10 on:]

Anyways, I was thinking about "coolest custom title"

Custom title?

D'oh, same as custom rank, I imagine.  Anyway, my grapes are too sour to approve of such a category.

[Reply #11 on:]

Hey gudbjorg, aren't you on the council? Shouldn't you know this stuff?

[Reply #12 on:]

I probably should, but this is all very big. Maybe you could personal message me and tell me what my role in the council is, and what the council does in general.

Anyways, I have no ideas for other awards (I do have some, I'll only post them as last resort, which is unlikely to happen).

[Reply #13 on:]

What about Peeler that looks most like a celebrity

[Reply #14 on:]

Yes, sounds good.

Is there an awards for just "Best Peeler"?

[Reply #15 on:]

 

[Reply #16 on:]

K, I suggest 15 categories max. We need to keep these awards exclusive and sought after.

I suggest:

• PEELer of the year
• PILF
• Best thread
• Best picture
• Best avatar
• Best signature
• Best Corrupt Despot Campaign
• Most addicted to PEEL
• Fantasy Mod
• WikiPEELia's golden contributor
• Best wiki entry
• Funniest PEELer
• Most Missed PEELer
• Least Intelligable (but still lovable) PEELer
• PEELer most like their PEEL persona

and also maybe a custom title should be given to the person who has done the most for the PEELies in ther time here? Something like "PEELies MC" but less lame.

In addition, 5 "non merit" (statistical awards) that don't depend on voting. Just nomination; ie: out of the nominees, the winner is the one whose profile statics best fit the award title. When the PEELies are finalised, we should have an award for the PEELer who has:

• the highest number of poll votes cast (eg: my profile says I have 388, anybody have more?)
• the highest number of topics started
• the highest postrate per day
• most posts in ONTOPIC areas of PEEL

and....

the PEELer who has the most smileys in their first post.

Yeah, some of them aren't going to be reusable, some of them don't relate to 2008, but screw it. This, I think, is the most effective way to re-boot the PEELies since nobody seems to give a fuck.

[Reply #17 on:]

We did have some statistic based ones last year that were in the "secret" awards section, such as "Least Likely to Win". I'd be fine with more like that, or as proposed by TNUK. It would be hard to track down the data accurately though.

[Reply #18 on:]

Just check the profile on the right day and the information will be in there.

[Reply #19 on:]

Yes, fine ideas except for some personal ones.

PEELer most like their PEEL persona would require having PEELer most unlike their PEEL persona too I'd think, both or neither.

[Reply #20 on:]

PEELer most like their PEEL persona would require having PEELer most unlike their PEEL persona too I'd think, both or neither.

We already had the one last year, so now we should have the other.

Yes, fine ideas except for some personal ones.

Personal ones??? Make sense plz.

[Reply #21 on:]

personal ones?... I think I hear santa outside... yes, let me .. seriously.. there's someone outside, everyone should be a... oh, it was the song i'm listening to..noooo....??? wtf, anyway, the last two awards in that list of yours seemed somehow, personal.

[Reply #22 on:]

I'm not likely to win either of them, so how are they personal?

Unless you mean I'm directing them against specific PEELers as personal attacks. I assure you, I'm not.

Dickhole.

[Reply #23 on:]

tnuk: re: yer q from the other thread..

Obvious wins:
PEELer of the year   
Best thread
Best picture
Best avatar
Funniest PEELer
Most addicted to PEEL
Fantasy Mod

Not-my-favorites-but-most-people-seem-to-like-them:
PILF                         
Least Intelligable (but still lovable) PEELer

No strong feelings whatsoever (fine categories, would be fine losing them for other awesome ideas, not that I have any at the moment):
Best signature
WikiPEELia's golden contributor
Best wiki entry
Most Missed PEELer
PEELer most like their PEEL persona

And finally...
Best Corrupt Despot Campaign
eh? Isn't there already an annual award for this - the corrupt despot title itself?

[Reply #24 on:]

Obvious wins? I don't even know how the awards winners are picked.

[Reply #25 on:]

K, I suggest 15 categories max. We need to keep these awards exclusive and sought after.

I suggest:

• PEELer of the year yes
  
  
• PILF yes
  
  
• Best thread yes
  
  
• Best picture yes
  
  
• Best avatar no, most stay the same
  
  
• Best signature same as above
  
  
• Best Corrupt Despot Campaign no
  
  
• Most addicted to PEEL yes
  
  
• Fantasy Mod probably
  
  
• WikiPEELia's golden contributor don't care
  
  
• Best wiki entry see above
  
  
• Funniest PEELer yes
  
  
• Most Missed PEELer no... maybe
  
  
• Least Intelligable (but still lovable) PEELer no
  
  
• PEELer most like their PEEL persona no
  
  and also maybe a custom title should be given to the person who has done the most for the PEELies in ther time here? Something like "PEELies MC" but less lame.
  
  In addition, 5 "non merit" (statistical awards) that don't depend on voting. Just nomination; ie: out of the nominees, the winner is the one whose profile statics best fit the award title. When the PEELies are finalised, we should have an award for the PEELer who has:
  
  
• the highest number of poll votes cast (eg: my profile says I have 388, anybody have more?)
• the highest number of topics started
• the highest postrate per day
• most posts in ONTOPIC areas of PEEL

and....

the PEELer who has the most smileys in their first post.

Yeah, some of them aren't going to be reusable, some of them don't relate to 2008, but screw it. This, I think, is the most effective way to re-boot the PEELies since nobody seems to give a fuck.

I still like Tay Zonday (most likely to be an internet celebrity), POTMOTY (though POTM has kinda fallen apart), and Least in Touch with Reality.

[Reply #26 on:]

Agree with Masty. Although if you must have a wikipeelia themed award, maybe keep it to one. I like the one about best entry. That's tangible.

[Reply #27 on:]

Hmmmm... what about "Most likely to be arrested on a morals charge".

[Reply #28 on:]

Statistic awards should be excluded.  It is arbitrary to actual PEELformance.

Also, is "sleeper" in that list a code word for "whore"?

[Reply #29 on:]

Last year people got upset that some of the awards were negative.... actually that's been a complaint for a few years.  I also agree with rach... we can drop wiki contributer for best wiki article, that sounds like fun. 

You could keep the avatar one and just make it say "best new avatar" since a lot of people, including new members, have gotten some neat new avatars.  Last year's winners of that award were really good.

Gudbjorg you should have gotten a url for the secret peelies discussion area, either by email or in #fc.  If you haven't, and assuming you're on the council, I'd ask Amy, since she's the head of council this year.
Also check this out:
http://splitmonkeys.de/wiki/index.php/PEELies

That has a little bit of information about PEELies and links to all the old award sites.  Someone (maybe me) could probably revamp that.... so that it's more informative on how the process works.... plus now that I think about it, I kind of want to remove all the winners listed on it, so people can visit the awards sites and (re)enjoy them as they were intended.

Btw, mom rules, what is a morals charge???

Edit: Yes DrThunder.  Just like we say PEELer I'd Like to Frak; PILF works nicely on its own.  Assuming nobody really takes offense to those, we might could retain them.  I think in general PEEL is mostly family friendly, so that's the thinking behind that.

[Reply #30 on:]

I still like Tay Zonday (most likely to be an internet celebrity), POTMOTY (though POTM has kinda fallen apart), and Least in Touch with Reality.

I agree with Masty on everything regarding Tnuk's proposed awards and would add that Least In Touch with Reality is a great idea.
I would also suggest a couple of less positive ones, just because they're fun. Such as:

• Worst Poster
• Shittiest Posting Gimmick
• Worst Avatar
• Easily trolled

Also, please no statistics based awards. It will only force people (me) to shitpost more.

[Reply #31 on:]

I got the link winna, maybe I should check there more often :S

[Reply #32 on:]

Okay, I picked my 15.

PEELer of the year
Funniest PEELer
PILF
Most prodigous finder of interesting stuff
Best thread
Best PEELer pic
Best WikiPEELia article
Best new PEELer
Best Fanartist/Fanfictionist
Most invaluable unPEELer
Best PEEL Game

Biggest attention whore
Biggest fanboy/fangirl
Creepiest PEELer
Angriest PEELer

The fanboy/fangirl one is not Futurama-specific, of course.

[Reply #33 on:]

Those sound pretty good... And I feel stupid for not thinking of combining Fanartist and Fanfictionist.... that's actually a good idea.

I personally don't have a problem with the negative awards; however, someone usually seems to take offense to it, and apparently we can't have anti-PEELies either.

Gudbjorg: Can you send me that link?  I think I forgot it.

[Reply #34 on:]

The problem with some of the negative ones is that some of them are too specific.  I'm thinking especially of the child molester award.  Internet is serious business and all that, but people who don't embrace that philosophy here and in real life might think "LOL pedophile!" isn't as entertaining as those of us voting for them.

[Reply #35 on:]

I can agree with that.... there's clearly a boundary there.  If I recall correctly, that was a combination with the stalker award clones we had, and Chris Hansen is hilarious.

Edit: I also assumed that I'd be a shoe-in

[Reply #36 on:]

And finally...
Best Corrupt Despot Campaign
eh? Isn't there already an annual award for this - the corrupt despot title itself?

Nah...the actual Corrupt Despot Election title is just "Person whose butt I want to kiss because they are kool on this message boards and I want them to say kool things about me so I'll be kool too."

But tnuk if we have this PEELie you won't throw a fit if no one votes for the hat will you?

So that's 2 reasons we shouldn't have it...Gopher is right (in theory).

[Reply #37 on:]

by "obvious win" I didn't mean the winner was obvious, I just meant the categories were obviously good, even essential, ones.

[Reply #38 on:]

To me I think 15 categories is very limiting but I do think we need no more than 30

Since there are few actually new ideas how about a category for Avatar makers. They are the unappreciated and underrated masters of this board.

Also, I don't think we should combine artist and fictionist. That limits the nominees for these even more.

One last thing. What if we make it so that one person can't win the same category for 2 or 3 years in a row. And make it so that specific categories (like best avatar) can't win twice with the same avatar or signature.

[Reply #39 on:]

Cram it Trickster!

I suggest 15 categories max. We need to keep these awards exclusive and sought after.