Oof, that “joke” pains me so. See, that’s an example of an objectively corny joke that seems a bit too proud of itself and therefore loses any minimal charm it might have possessed. The “getting the brain out” joke is borderline to me, too, though in that case it’s harder for me to articulate why. I think it has traces of that winking quality that I so despise—like, it has the cadence of a joke, a malapropism, when what I actually prefer are lines that are a bit more plainspoken and unadorned, where you can almost see the gears of the character’s mind turning (and perhaps malfunctioning) as they say it.
I know I’m not making much sense. The best example of this I can think of is actually from
The Simpsons—and, perhaps significantly, from the era in which DXC and Ken Keeler were writers on the show. It’s this exchange between Bart and Lisa from “The Secret War of Lisa Simpson”:
Lisa: Maybe everyone would be better off if I just quit.
Bart: But if you quit, it’d be like an expert knot-tier quitting a knot-tying contest right in the middle of tying a knot!
Lisa: Why’d you say that?
Bart: I don’t know, I was just looking at my shoelaces.
Like, this is perhaps the perfect distillation of my sense of humor, my platonic ideal of a good joke. You have the clunky analogy from Bart, which is amusing enough, but then Lisa picking at the weirdness of it and Bart admitting where it came from—and the answer itself being so banal, the opposite of revelatory—is what puts it over the edge for me.
So maybe what I like best are jokes that on the surface should not read as jokes at all, but some combination of the cadence and the delivery just do it for me? Like, I’m less impressed by the cleverness of the language itself—in fact, the dumber the better—but am drawn to the overall construction of the joke? I’m fumbling here, I know, but this is honestly the best way I can think of to describe it.
Edit: Actually, you know what, here’s another
Futurama example to prove my point. “They’re the beaniest!” from “A Leela of Her Own” is honestly one of my favorite lines in the entire series. This is an objectively dumb joke, but the underlying mechanism/assumption of the joke—that we generally form superlatives in English by adding the suffix “-est”—and then the misapplication of that grammatical rule that results in the non-word “beaniest,” is what makes it so funny to me. It’s that truism about writing, that you have to know the rules of the English language before you’re able to break them—it amuses me to no end when those rules are broken and result in the least eloquent diction and/or syntax possible.
I am fully aware of the fact that I sound like the world’s biggest asshole right now, but I am unabashedly pleased to have lit upon an explanation for why I find this stuff so funny. Thank you for coming to my TED Talk or whatever.