PEEL viewers' greatest episodes (group consensus)

[#600 :]

Yet again, I'm going with 'Bender's Big Score'.

[#601 :]

Anthology Of Interest II and How Hermes Requisitioned His Groove Back.

[#602 :]

Yet again, I'm going with 'Bender's Big Score'.

THIRD.

[#603 :]

Sorry guys it took so long to get this up....I have been quite busy lately.  Thanks for your patience.  Poll's up!

[#604 :]

*Bump to top of Page*

Only 8 votes so far.

[#605 :]

I see this is for the consensus of the 23rd best episode. Is there a list of the consensuses for the 1st-22nd best episodes?

[#606 :]

Yes, look back one page at post #594 and you will see the "standings" up to here.

[#607 :]

Ah, gratzi. I just put my vote in for Bender's Big Score. It was a touch class between BBS and Anthology of Interest II, but the two songs in BBS won me over.

[#608 :]

Cool....after every round, I post the round's stats and an updated version of the list.  Then everyone makes 1-2 nominations for what episodes they would like to see included in the next poll.  I choose the "best"/most nominated 4-5 episodes and people vote...we are at that point right now.

Also: I use THIS link of rated episodes (post #46) as a guide.  As I state in each round, if you nominate an episode considered to be one of the "best" episodes, it usually will be included in the poll.  However, if you nominate, for example, an episode rated in the 50s at this point, unless you give a great explanation and/or get additional people to nominate it, it usually will not be included in the poll.

[#609 :]

I went with AOI II, but to be honest there's a lot of great choices there...

[#610 :]

I have to go with BBS, because it was a quite excellent episode movie and deserves to be within the top 25. The other episodes are also good...

[#611 :]

Despite all of its innate weirdness, BBS is probably my favorite of the four movies. It's still hard to choose, though.

[#612 :]

Any last minute votes?  Poll to close soon.

[#613 :]

If I make a clone of my own or a time travel duplicate, do I get two votes?

[#614 :]

Gotta be BBS. I mean...come on.

[#615 :]

Yeah, I mean it's like... come on.

[#616 :]

If I make a clone of my own or a time travel duplicate, do I get two votes?

No.  Your car does not reach 88 mphs.  Sorry.

Yeah, I mean it's like... come on.

Well, it's time to close the poll and like....come on...your choice did not win. 

[#617 :]

After 22 votes, the winner for the 23rd best Futurama episode of all time is:
Anthology of Interest II with 10 votes (45.5%).
Bender's Big Score had 6 votes (27.3%)
The Problem with Popplers had 4 votes (18.2%)
War is the H-Word had 1 vote (4.5%)
Future Stock had 1 vote (4.5%)


So to recap, voted the best Futurama episode of all time: Roswell that Ends Well
The 2nd best Futurama episode of all time: The Luck of the Fryrish
The 3rd best Futurama episode of all time: The Sting
The 4th best Futurama episode of all time: The Late Philip J Fry
The 5th best Futurama episode of all time: Parasites Lost
The 6th best Futurama episode of all time: The Farnsworth Parabox
The 7th best Futurama episode of all time: The Devil's Hands Are Idle Playthings
The 8th best Futurama episode of all time: Space Pilot 3000
The 9th best Futurama episode of all time: Time Keeps on Slippin'
The 10th best Futurama episode of all time: Jurassic Bark
The 11th best Futurama episode of all time: The Why of Fry
The 12th best Futurama episode of all time: Amazon Women in the Mood
The 13th best Futurama episode of all time: The Prisoner of Benda
The 14th best Futurama episode of all time: Teenage Mutant Leela's Hurdles
The 15th best Futurama episode of all time: Where No Fan Has Gone Before
The 16th best Futurama episode of all time: Insane in the Mainframe
The 17th best Futurama episode of all time: A Flight to Remember
The 18th best Futurama episode of all time: Leela's Homeworld
The 19th best Futurama episode of all time: Godfellas
The 20th best Futurama episode of all time: The Day the Earth Stood Stupid
The 21st best Futurama episode of all time: Hell is Other Robots
The 22nd best Futurama episode of all time: Anthology of Interest I
The 23rd best Futurama episode of all time: Anthology of Interest II

Now it is time to state your vote for the 24th best Futurama episode of all time (with all previous episode winners obviously being out of vote consideration).

Remember (again), if you want your choice of episode in the poll, you need to state your opinion...especially if it is not normally considered a top 20-30ish episode....a lone nomination for an episode out of this range usually does not garner inclusion in the poll.

[#618 :]

Love and Rocket.
I've given up on Future Stock for the moment. Maybe a bit later I'll start nominating it again when I'm not the only one.

[#619 :]

I found it interesting AoI 1 and 2 came off the board in consecutive rounds...especially when AoI 2 finished with only 2 votes the previous round.


As a refresher:  UPDATED

As a guide, here are some of the "highest" rated episodes according to the list that have yet to win.

When Aliens Attack (#25)
War is the H-Word (#27)
Love's Labors Lost in Space (#29)
Three Hundred Big Boys (#30)
The Problem with Popplers (#31)
The Series has Landed (#32)
I, Roommate (#35)
X-Mas Story (T#35)
Bender's Big Score (T#35)


Also included on the list, but has not won yet:
A Clockwork Origin (#16)
Lethal Inspection (#20)
The Mutants are Revolting (#22)
Rebirth (#28)

I included the season 6A episodes separately because, personally, I feel they were ranked way too high on the original list since it was created shortly after these episodes aired....now that there has been some time, these episodes are being slotted more appropriately.  [Hence another reason why I am not ranking Season 6B episodes at this point.]


Please keep in mind this list is not a, "you must nominate from these episodes", but merely a guide to help you remember older episodes.

[#620 :]

I Roommate.

[#621 :]

Bender's Big Score.

[#622 :]

^This.

[#623 :]

Once again, "The Problem with Popplers". I'll keep nominating it until it wins.

I was pretty sure it was a shoo-in for 22nd, but then AOI took over it out of nowhere.

[#624 :]

Bender's Big Score.

[#625 :]

Free Hot Meal,

If you are looking to satisfying a quota regarding the amount of people who nominate an episode before opening up the next poll, then allow me to voice my support for The Problem With Popplers and Bender's Big Score - both already nominated. If not, then disregard this message entirely and feel free to flame my inbox.

[#626 :]

How Hermes Requisitioned His Groove Back and Love And Rocket.

[#627 :]

How Hermes Requisitioned His Groove Back and The Prisoner of Benda.

[#628 :]

The Prisoner of Benda has already made it through.

Love And Rocket

Finally, some support!

[#629 :]

I was pretty sure it was a shoo-in for 22nd, but then AOI took over it out of nowhere.

So was I when I logged on to close the poll.  In one day it went from down 4 votes, to up 2 votes, I believe.

Free Hot Meal,

If you are looking to satisfying a quota regarding the amount of people who nominate an episode before opening up the next poll, then allow me to voice my support for The Problem With Popplers and Bender's Big Score - both already nominated. If not, then disregard this message entirely and feel free to flame my inbox.

There is no "quota", but the more the merrier.   So feel free to do it for each round.  Seconding, thirding, ect an episode really makes it clear to me said episode should be included in the poll.

[#630 :]

Any more nominations or "Seconds"?  Otherwise, the poll will be put together in the near future.

[#631 :]

Any more nominations or "Seconds"?  Otherwise, the poll will be put together in the near future.

A Clone Of My Own for my 3rd nomination. I think it would do well in the polls.

EDIT - I also second I Roommate too.

[#632 :]

I, Roommate

[#633 :]

Sorry, I seriously slacked off on this.  Thanks for your patience.  A new poll is opened!  Hooray!!!!

Some great choices, get voting!

[#634 :]

How Hermes Requisitioned His Groove Back

[#635 :]

I, Roommate

[#636 :]

I, Roommate. I can't say it is the funniest or the most touching episode, but something about it just always makes me happy to see it.

[#637 :]

HHRHGB, TPWP, and IR are all about equal in quality.

I voted for TPWP.

[#638 :]

Tough choices, but I went with How Hermes Requisitioned His Groove Back.

[#639 :]

I went with BBS, I think it should've been voted in long ago.
And for the heck of it, here's how I list the available options from best to least awesome:
1) Bender's Big Score
2a) How Hermes Requisitioned His Groove Back
2b) The Problem with Popplers
4) I, Roommate
5) A Clone of my Own