Nominees so far:
1. Bender: Bite my shiny metal ass (general catchphrase)
2. Zapp: Stop exploding you cowards!(when aliens attack)
3. Bender: Oh crap! It's a miracle!(Bendin' in the wind)
4. Fry: Why am I sticky and naked? Did I miss something fun?(The sting)
5. Fry: My God... a million years.(space pilot 3000)
6. Prof Farnsworth: Buddha, Zeus, God, one of you guys do something! Satan, you owe me!(The Farnsworth Parabox)
7. Fry: I did do the nasty in the pasty!(The why of fry)
8.Zapp: You win again gravity (Amazon women in the mood)
9.Fry: Brain! brain make people dumb (The Day the Earth Stood Stupid)
10.Chester A. Arthur:Chester A. Arthur fall down (the day the earth stood stupid)
11.Zapp:These balls are making me testy (war is the H-word)
12.Zapp:Balls throughly licked(war is the H-word)
13.Hermies:Sweet three-toed-sloth of Ice-Planet Hoth (The sting)
14.Fry:You can't give up hope just because it's hopeless. You gotta to hope even more and cover your ears, and go bla bla bla bla bla bla(Godfellas)
15.God:When you do things right, people won't be sure if you've done anything at all(Godfellas)
16.Narrator:You watched it, you can't unwatch it stay tuned for more tales of interest.(Anthology of interests I+II)
17.Bender: I see my antenna is lower, I better wiggle it for better reception Fry: No you'll make god cry (anthology of interest II)
18.Prof Farnsworth: My god they'll be killed on our doorstep! And there's no trash pickup till January third! (X-mas story)
19.Zapp:wait what are you people idiots? I'm still going mano a mano with this envelope. (The lesser of 2 evils)
20.Zapp:If we can hit that bullseye the rest of the dominoes will fall like a house of cards. Checkmate (When aliens attack)
21.Leela:I'll find Fry's coffin, take his corpse and keep it under my mattress to remind me he's really dead. That'll prove I'm not insane.(the sting)
22.Zapp:What are you, gay? (amazon women in the mood)
23.Zoidberg:Gracias (when aliens attack)
24.Morbo:Ha Ha Ha kittens give Morbo gas (a big piece of garbage)
25.Bender: Hand me the Becktionary. [A man offers him the book.] No, no, the rhyming Becktionary. (Bendin' in the Wind)
26.Leela: Please don't stop playing Fry. I wanna hear how it ends.(The Devil's Hands are Idle Playthings)
27.Bender: Your Mamas so fat she has high risk of diabetes and heart disease.(Futurama Comics (#15 UK)- The Bender You Say)
28.Bender:Oh Your GOD!(Amazon women in the mood)
29.Ipgee: Oh my various gods X-ray specks!(How hermies requisitioned his groove back)
30.Terry: Welcome to the world of tomorrow (space pilot 3000)
31.Kif:If I said you had a beautiful body would you take your pants off and dance around a little? (Amazon women in the mood)
32.Neutral leader: If I die tell my wife hello (Brannigan begin again)
33.Fry: But... Bender need brain... for... smart making.(How Hermes Recquisitioned His Groove Back)
34.Lrrr: this concept of wuv confuses and infuriates us! (Love and Rocket)
35.Guardbot #2: Which of the following would you most prefer? A: A puppy, B: A pretty flower from your sweetie, or C: A large properly-formatted data file?(Fear Of A Bot Planet)
36.Bender: Ah! I got a good vibe from this place: Nice long dinner table, quiet, well-behaved spiders, graveyard-adjacent.(The Honking)
37.Bender: Yeah? Well I don't believe in Santa Claus. Come on everybody, if you don't believe in him he can't hurt you. [Santa whacks Bender over the head with his sack.]
Ow! God! The pain! (Xmas Story)
38.Zapp:Brannigan's Law is like Brannigan's Love: hard and fast! (Love labours lost in space)
39.Sal:what do I look like- a guy who ain't lazy? (the series has landed)
40.Prof Farnsworth:Oh, a lesson in history from mister I'm-my-own-grandpa! Let's just get the heck outta here! Scr** history! (Roswell that ends well)
41.Mayor Wait a minute, your not Santa Claus, how dare you lie in front of Jesus (a tale of 2 santas)
42."Robot Devil: Give me back my hands! These things are always touching me in places.
Fry: Yeah, they get around." ( TDHAIPT)
43.Liubot: "I'll always remember you Phillip J. Fry...MEMORY DELETED" (I dated a Robot)
44.Fry: Space. It seems to go on and on forever. But then you get to the end and a gorilla starts throwing barrels at you. (Space pilot 3000)
45.Fry: That's the saltiest thing I ever tasted, and I once ate a big heaping bowl of salt. (My Three Suns)
46.Professor Farnsworth: Ah, to be young again... and also a robot. (E2:TSHL)
47.Fry: It's every man for himself!(Sinks in quick moon sand) Help me Leela! (Episode 2: TSHL)
48.I find the best part of a women is the boobies (Amazon women in the mood)
49.Bender:Thats what makes it SO funny!(Laughs... well weirdly)
Okay he wasn't joking now shut up and follow me (Farnsworth Parabox)
50.Fry: I have Talking Hump Syndrome. (A Clone of my Own)
51. Zoidberg: Help! A guinnea pig tricked me. (Anthology of Interest I)
52. Sal: Theres the world's drinking water is safe for another day. (Teenage Mutant Leela's Hurdles)
53. Bender: Those could be anyone's thoughts fat ass. (I, Roomate)
Well I have added to i_c_weiner's list. I left out one or two quotes suggested by rigter85 just because they didn't have the episodes.
So I guess we should be ready to vote now more or less.
Edit (great function isn't it?!): quote 52. and 50.
------------------
know your rights!