I'm going to go with:
1) Javier over at TFP. His site has stayed original over the years, and his layouts are great!
2) JasonCGEF because he's awesome. (hahahaha slimmy)
3) SlimmyCGEF because of those comics he did.
4) Umm... I guess [-mArc-] because he realized the newsgroups contained nerds.
5) I guess I'll give this to Leandro... he's kept TLZ running pretty well, and he's got a decent eye for layouts as well. I'll never call it FMH though.
6) I'm editing in Jarnik because I always loved his site.... maybe the mostest.
7) Gort. Busy guy, fun to hang around... I wonder where he is.....
8) PaulFSAC.... he was the original scan master.
That's a decent list... I don't know how to round out the top 10.... that guy who ran TFO would probably be up there, but I never learned his name before it shut down..... and he had a no robots thing on his site, so it's not even archived on the way back machine....
I wonder when my next FFOR will come in.