Danny you do not need to explain yourself. I saw the exact post back then that you are talking about. Sometimes you just gotta use your best judgment with these things - given the thread date and page number of the current thread, I myself would rationalize that it probably wouldn't do well.
When creating threads I ask myself, is this thread unique enough that I could possibly see it hitting the 20 page mark in the forseeable future, or ever? If the answer is no, I typically don't do it. But who knows. Maybe you'll get fifty Captain Sweatpants from the comic store to sign up and vote
I haven't read the comic yet, so I can't properly respond...I must say in general though, after I read the comics I don't get an urge to talk about it, unless something was pointed out to me like a Kazaleh drawing or canon inconsistency. Nerd.
Also I'd like to point out you started the thread without giving us your thoughts. Rookie mistake!
(Before you say it, yes I know they do that with the episodes in General, but typically those threads are started before the episode airs).